Rediscover a Timeless Melody: “It Doesn’t Matter Anymore” by Daniel O’Donnell with Mary Duff (2005)
In the age of rapidly changing musical trends and digital overproduction, there’s a rare comfort found in the tender strains of a duet that prioritizes simplicity, sincerity, and gentle reflection. Such is the enduring charm of “It Doesn’t Matter Anymore”, a beautifully rendered collaboration between Irish singer Daniel O’Donnell and his long-time musical partner, Mary Duff. Originally released in 2005, their rendition of this classic evokes a deep sense of nostalgia while breathing new life into a familiar ballad.
Written by Paul Anka and first popularized by Buddy Holly in 1958, “It Doesn’t Matter Anymore” carries a bittersweet tone — a reflection on acceptance and moving forward when circumstances change. With its soothing melody and heartfelt lyrics, the song has been covered by a variety of artists over the decades, but few interpretations bring the same warmth and sincerity as this duet by O’Donnell and Duff. Their voices blend seamlessly, capturing a quietly contemplative mood that speaks volumes in its restraint.
Daniel O’Donnell, often referred to as the “Irish Prince of Country and Easy Listening,” has spent decades building a reputation as one of the gentlest and most beloved entertainers in the British Isles and beyond. Known for his friendly demeanor and melodic arrangements, O’Donnell’s appeal among mature audiences is well-earned. His performances are never rushed, never forced—they simply invite listeners into a space both familiar and comforting.
In Mary Duff, O’Donnell finds a musical partner whose style matches his own with striking compatibility. Together, their rendition of “It Doesn’t Matter Anymore” becomes more than just a nod to nostalgia. It becomes a heartfelt expression of humility and perspective. There is a quiet confidence in both singers’ delivery, a feeling that they are not merely performing the lyrics but understanding and embodying their sentiment.
What makes this version particularly affecting is its simplicity. With minimal instrumentation and an intimate arrangement, the emphasis remains on emotion rather than embellishment. Friends and fans who enjoy duets grounded in authenticity will likely find this recording refreshingly unpretentious. It’s a return to the kind of music that prioritizes melody, harmony, and emotional integrity over theatrics.
Whether you’re a long-time admirer of Daniel O’Donnell or Mary Duff, or simply someone seeking music rooted in gentle reflection, this track offers a kind of musical “exhale.” It reminds us that while some things indeed no longer matter, the memory and meaning carried within a well-sung melody still do.